Big news! We’ve added new housing program data - check them out under “Housing Programs” on each city page.
Housing programs are the strategies that cities and counties legally have at their disposal to produce more and preserve existing affordable housing, as well as protect existing residents from getting displaced from their homes and communities.
Local housing programs, as part of a housing element, have significant impacts on a city or county reaching its affordable housing goals. Each additional housing policy has a significant impact on the residents who are most in need of affordable housing. However, the number of programs that a jurisdiction includes in their housing element is not meant to imply how well a city or county is addressing local housing needs since the quality and impact of each will need to be determined as well.
Use the below data to explore this jurisdiction’s approaches to affirmatively furthering fair housing for the 6th element cycle, and review the actions, deliverables, and deadlines committed to for each program.
PROGRAM NUMBER | ACTIONS | DELIVERABLE | DELIVERABLE DATE |
---|---|---|---|
3.4.7 | Oakland has a diverse historic urban fabric, some of
which no longer conforms to the current Planning
Code. To capture and continue this diversity and
remove ambiguities, the City will reduce minimum
lot sizes and setbacks to facilitate the creation of
small-lot developments, as well as legitimize the
many existing small-lot neighborhood patterns
in West Oakland and other neighborhoods.
The City will conduct a comprehensive review
of the Planning Code to identify where current
development standards have created nonconformities for older built facilities and amend
development standards to reduce or eliminate
them where appropriate. The City will also provide
flexibility in the objective standards to retain and
promote the City’s vernacular built environment.
| Reduce constraints on development to significantly increase production of
housing to match housing need.
| 2023 – 2026 |
1.1.6 | Housing Related legal services will help address displacement risks,
eviction defense, and housing instability through
legal representation, consultation, and education.
| Resources permitting, all at risk tenants may seek free legal services from external
partners to prevent evictions and housing
instability.
| In July 2022 Council approved a direct grant to a consortium of nonprofit legal service providers to continue eviction protection and other legal services. Other tenant legal service contracts are administered through the Rent Adjustment Program. Staff will continue to seek funding to ensure services will be ongoing. |
1.1.2 | Just Cause for Eviction protections are enforced
by the Rent Adjustment Program (RAP) and are
contained within Chapter 8.22, Article II of the
Oakland Municipal Code. In 2022, the City Council
voted to place on the November 2022 ballot an
expansion of the Just Cause for Eviction ordinance.
In particular, the ballot measures asks: Shall the
Measure amending the Just Cause for Eviction
Ordinance to: (1) prohibit no-fault evictions of
children and educators during the school year;
(2) extend eviction protections to tenants in
recreational vehicles (RVs), tiny homes on wheels,
and newly constructed units except during the
first 10 years after issuance of the certificate of
occupancy; (3) remove failure to sign a new lease as
grounds for eviction; and (4) make other clarifying
amendments, be adopted? The City will continue
to enforce just cause measures, undertake efforts
to ensure the public is aware of revisions if enacted
by the voters, and expand tenant protections
as feasible—including identifying additional
limitations to just causes.
| All tenant rights and protections
under applicable City and State law will be
enforced.
| Ongoing, 2023-2031 |
3.3.9 | Affordable housing developers have pointed
to the impact of City fees and the timing of fee
payment, including impact fees, building permits,
and public art requirements, as constraints to
development. The City currently requires for
Affordable Housing Impact Fees only one-half of
the amount of impact fees to be paid before permit
issuance and the remaining half to be paid before
the issuance of Certificate Of Occupancy (COO),
while the Transportation and Capital Improvement
Impact Fees are paid in full before building permit
issuance. The City also defers other fees such as
public art and school tax. The City will explore
additional ways to increase flexibility in payment
timing and potential fee reductions and/or waivers
to reduce the burden imposed by the collection of
City fees and requirements.
| Explore methods to reduce cost
burden of City fees and payment timing to
significantly increase affordable housing
development.
| Review and update where possible Impact Fee and other payment timing as well as fees charged by mid-2024. |
3.6.2 | The City will provide increased flexibility in
development standards, with a focus on smaller
infill residential projects, to ensure that these
projects can qualify for streamlined permitting
without need for variances. The City will also
consider increasing staff-level authority, with clear
guidelines, to grant minor exceptions without
the need for a variance, which can also reduce
project timelines and costs. Alongside the efforts
described in Actions 3.2.1, this flexibility will increase
the capacity of the Planning Bureau to permit a
variety of units, more expediently, creating more
residential units in traditionally lower-density
neighborhoods.
| Significantly increase production of
housing projects, specifically by low-income
and nonprofit builders, to match housing need.
| 2023 – 2025 and ongoing |
3.3.19 | The City will also assess
the effectiveness of its AFFH programs (including
Action 3.3.6), including sites that develop in higher
resource areas , displacement strategies and placebased strategies toward community revitalization.
In addition, in 2027, the City will audit all pipeline
projects credited in the inventory and, if necessary,
identify additional capacity or rezone additional
sites and maintain adequate sites to accommodate
the RHNA by income group.
| Identify and monitor adequate sites
available for development, and increase the
baseline of affordable units in high-resource
areas | Audit pipeline projects as part of mid-cycle (2027) review and, if necessary, rezone additional sites by the end of 2027. |
3.3.17 | The City will continue to work with low-income,
grassroots, and BIPOC af fordable housing
developers to identify barriers that prevent BIPOC
and small nonprofit developers from accessing City
funding and navigating the permitting process. The
city will continue to develop solutions to ensure that
the permitting process is transparent, affordable,
and accessible for these Emerging Developers,
defined by Oakland HCD as “a developer who has
less than five (5) years of experience as a developer
and/or less than five completed projects.” The
City has secured a Breakthrough Grant from
the Partnership for the Bay’s Future that will
dedicate a full time fellow to facilitate this work of
identifying and breaking down barriers for BIPOC
and emerging developers to develop affordable
housing in Oakland.
| The proportion of City funding distributed for affordable housing development to
low-income, grassroots and BIPOC affordable
housing developers will significantly increase
by 2031.
| The City’s Breakthrough Grant Fellow is currently researching and implementing strategies to address this action item from 2022 to 2024. |
3.2.7 | With limited exceptions in single-family homes
with a CUP for a traditional owner-run bed and
breakfast, Oakland’s current planning regulations
prohibit any rental of an accessory dwelling unit
(ADU), single-family home, duplex, apartment/
condo, live/work unit, or other dwelling unit for
less than 30 consecutive days. In addition, State
laws that govern ADUs do not allow for any ADU
to be rented as a short-term rental of less than
30 consecutive days. The City’s code compliance
division reviews zoning code violations on a
complaint-driven basis, which has not sufficiently
deterred property owners from operating shortterm rentals that do not comply with planning
regulations. Additionally, code compliance often
lacks sufficient evidence to clearly document that
an ADU or other dwelling unit is operating as a
short-term rental.
In response, the City will pursue additional data
collection tools that will allow the City to access
information showing addresses of units listed on
short-term rental platforms. Upon securing this
data, the City will engage in proactive enforcement
against property owners who are operating short
term rentals in ADUs and in other dwelling units
throughout the City.
| Reduce the number of unauthorized short-term rentals in Oakland by having
bi-yearly data scrapes of short-term rental
platforms and automatic mailing notifications
to owners in violation. | Secure additional data collection tools and begin proactive enforcement in 2023. Complaint-based enforcement is ongoing and would continue, supplemented by the additional data collection tools. |
1.1.4 | On January 16, 2018, the City of Oakland passed the
Uniform Residential Tenant Relocation Ordinance
(Ord. No. 13468) to establish a uniform schedule
of relocation payments which are now extended
to tenants evicted when the owner or qualifying
relative moves in and for other “no tenant fault”
evictions. The Uniform Relocation Ordinance (Ord.
No. 13468) requires owners to provide relocation
payments to tenants displaced by code compliance
activities, owner or relative move-ins, Ellis Act
activity, and condominium conversions. The
City will continue to implement and enforce the
Ordinance, adjusting base payments for inflation
annually on July 1st. Additional relocation payments
shall be required for tenant households in rental
units that include lower-income, elderly or disabled
tenants, and/or minor children.
| All tenant rights and protections
under applicable City and State law will be
enforced.
| Ongoing, 2023-2031 |
2.2.7 | The City will consider allowing owners of residential
hotels that agree to restrict occupancy to lowerincome residents to transfer development rights to
create an endowed source of funding for an internal
subsidy for such residents, or for maintenance/
facility upgrades that do not increase rents.
| Preserve SROs and meet housing
need.
| 2025-2027 |
4.1.4 | Recognizing that a lack of access to living wage jobs
is a significant driver of homelessness in Oakland,
the City will work with the Oakland Unified School
District (OUSD), higher educational institutions,
related nonprofit agencies, business and other
partners to create low barrier work opportunities
for people who are currently unsheltered. These
programs will offer support for development of
work-related skills, provide services to address
employment barriers specifically targeted to the
needs of unhoused residents and increase the
co-location and collaboration between providers
of homeless assistance and employment programs
and services. In addition, the City will work to
match small business owners who want to address
homelessness with job seekers who are homeless
or formerly homeless.
Strategies to include:
• Low barrier work opportunities, for people
rentering the workforce
• Add employment specialist positions in
core homeless services/prevention services
programs
• Flexible funding pool to support career track
training and employment programs
• Benefits advocacy to obtain SSI or other
income for which they are eligible
| Reduction in the number of households which return to homelessness in the two
years after obtaining housing.
| Increase and expand support for systems navigation, social services, and employment by 2031. Continue development and implementation of low barrier work 106 opportunity programs in partnership with OUSD and other partners by end of 2026. Develop and implement programs to match small business owners with job seekers who are homeless or formerly homeless by end of 2026. |
1.1.12 | Oakland Municipal Code [Chapter 15.63] grants
preference in City-assisted affordable housing
projects to (1) Oakland residents displaced
due to City actions or no-fault evictions, (2)
neighborhood residents, and (3) Oakland residents
and workers. All three preferences are applied
at initial occupancy, to the extent permitted by
other funding sources. After initial occupancy,
displaced households and Oakland residents and
workers continue to receive priority preference for
available units. Oakland’s Housing and Community
Development Department recently updated its
findings to support its preferences and ensure
that its preferences may be permitted in Countyassisted projects. The City will continue its efforts to
streamline the process by which these preferences
are applied, including through a regional housing
portal and a more robust tracking system for
displaced households.
| The City will continue to apply local
preferences in City-assisted affordable housing to the extent allowed by law and the constraints of other involved funding sources. The
City will continue to identify ways to streamline
the administration of its preferences, including through a regional housing portal and a
more robust tracking system for displaced
households.
| Ongoing, 2023-2031. While the ability of the City to require its projects to participate in a regional application portal depends in part on the readiness of such portals, the City currently attends regular meetings around the design of a regional portal. The City intends to identify a suitable application portal to partner with by the end of 2024. |
1.1.14 | Keep Oakland Housed, the Shallow Subsidy Pilot
(public-private partnerships), Oakland Housing
Secure, and the federally funded Emergency
Rental Assistance Program (ERAP) are programs
that currently help prevent renters from becoming
homeless through rental assistance, legal advice,
housing counseling, and/or case management.
Through these programs, a diverse and vibrant
network of providers has been created that work
together to provide individualized services to
Oakland tenants.
The City will support and align City, Alameda
County, and private partners (such as communitybased and faith-based organizations that have
roots in communities whose members are
disproportionately at risk of homelessness) to
strengthen their capacity to prevent displacement
and respond ef fectively when people are
experiencing a housing crisis. The City will also
expand these types of programs and design new
ones that identify, assist, and prioritize funding
for those who are most at risk of becoming
homeless. In addition, the City will continue to
make information about tenant protection, antidisplacement, rental assistance, and homelessness
services available on the City’s website and at City
facilities and strive to improve public awareness of
these programs. These efforts are especially key in
the wake of the COVID-19 crisis and the eventual
end of the eviction moratorium. Additional tenant
protection actions are included in Actions 1.1.1-1.1.10.
| The City of Oakland will continue
to implement a homeless prevention program
that includes emergency financial assistance,
legal support and wrap around services. The
program will be an extension of previous
homeless prevention programs such as Keep
Oakland Housed, Oakland Housing Secure, and
the Emergency Rental Assistance Program. | Continue implementation of the ERAP program 2022-2023, and The City of Oakland to issue a Request for Proposals and award a contract to a homeless prevention program provider(s) by mid 2023. |
5.2.5 | As funding becomes available, the City will
continue to operate loan programs to help property
owners afford the cost of seismic safety programs.
In the past, these loan programs have particularly
focused on soft story retrofit projects. The City
will also continue to implement the City’s soft
story retrofit ordinance, which requires vulnerable
apartment buildings to retrofit soft story areas at
risk of collapse.
| Successfully retrofit all vulnerable soft-story residential buildings at risk of
collapse.
| Ongoing, 2023 - 2031 |
2.2.6 | The practice of “house flipping,” —acquiring
properties, making superficial improvements,
and quickly reselling at a higher price—can cause
housing costs to increase, leading to higher rates
of displacement and increased exclusivity in higher
resource neighborhoods. To curb the negative
effects of speculation, the City will consider
implementing an anti-speculation tax, which would
apply a fee when a property is sold shortly after
purchase. The City will conduct a market study to
understand the potential impacts of such a tax and
its appropriateness within Oakland. As discussed
in Action 2.2.8, the City will also explore a possible
Tenant Opportunity to Purchase/Community
Opportunity to Purchase Act.
| Study the root causes of unaffordability and displacement and consider possible
taxes to prevent displacement and maintain
affordability. Looking specifically at the cost
to rehabilitate a home and incentivizing the
market to maintain neighborhood level affordability through tax incentive or disincentive.
| 2026 |
5.1.2 | Through the first-time homebuyer programs
described in Action 5.1.1, the City was able to
issue 121 loans totaling approximately $6.8 million
during the previous planning period. With
appropriate funding, these low-cost financing
options have been very effective in promoting
affordable homeownership. The City will continue
to seek funding for these programs and to refer
homebuyers to resources related to other county,
State, or federal level funding – including through
the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB),
California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA),
Golden State Finance Authority (GSFA), Federal
Home Loan Bank’s (FHLB) WISH Program, Alameda
County AC Boost, and Alameda County Mortgage
Credit Certificate.
| If the City of Oakland receives
CalHome grants and other homeownership
funding at historic rates, the City expects to
support a total of 160 low- and moderate-income households with home purchases over
the next Housing Element cycle.
| Ongoing as funding is available, 2023-2031; Annual reporting on first time homebuyer program data |
2.2.4 | The conversion of rental housing to condominiums
provides a risk to the affordability of Oakland’s
housing stock. The City recently amended its
condominium conversion regulations to require
replacement rental housing for the conversion of
two or more housing units, to remove the provision
allowing the generation of conversion rights when
the units are offered as rental units for seven or
more years, to acknowledge the applicability of the
Oakland Just Cause for Eviction Ordinance and the
Oakland Rent Adjustment Ordinance, and to afford
greater rights and protections to existing tenants.
The City will strictly enforce these recently adopted
regulations to preserve Oakland’s rental housing
supply.
| Continue to enforce condominium
conversion regulations to preserve rental housing supply and prevent displacement.
| Ongoing, 2023-2031 |
3.5.2 | Formal and informal housing cooperatives, co-living
and cohousing models in Oakland have traditionally
provided an alternative form of affordable housing,
including ownership housing. To further support
these initiatives, the City will conduct outreach
with community-based organizations and other
community partners to identify ways the City can
support these models, especially for lower-income
residents. The City will prioritize lower-income
residents and residents at risk of displacement
when supporting these alternative housing models.
The City will study how the Planning Code and
building occupancy standards affect the viability
of these models. The Oakland Department of
Housing and Community Development will also
continue to support cooperatives and community
land trusts through its Acquisition and Conversion
to Affordable Housing program.
| Oakland Department of Housing
and Community Development will continue
to make funds available to housing cooperatives as per current practice. The City will also
include cooperatives, co-living and cohousing
models in its study of the Planning Code and
building occupancy standards.
| Since 2019, the Acquisition and Conversion to Affordable Housing (ACAH) program has included set-asides for coops and community land trusts, based on input received from community stakeholders. $12 million was allocated through the 2019-2021 budget, and t City will continue to implement a significant set-aside in future ACAH NOFAs, which are expected to be issued at least every other year through the 2023-2031 Housing Element cycle depending on staffing capacity and funding availability. The next ACAH NOFA is anticipated to be released in December 2022 (see Action 3.3.10). Planning Code amendments permitting rooming house facilities/SROs will be completed by June – July 2023 under Action 3.7.6. In 2024-2025 the City will study the Planning Code and building occupancy standards as well as part of the update to the Land Use and Transportation Element (LUTE) and Planning Code |
3.4.3 | Conditional Use Permits (CUPs) are currently
re quire d for multi- unit buildings in the
RD-2 and RM Zones, which can act as a constraint
on development – especially for affordable housing.
The City will revise regulations to permit multi-unit
buildings according to objective criteria such as
by building type and development size, without
subjecting multi-unit residential projects to CUPs.
Under Action 3.4.8, the City will create objective
design standards and amend the Planning Code
design review procedures to allow for streamlined,
ministerial approval. The City will also actively
promote and support use of SB 35 to streamline
100 percent affordable housing developments.
These revised standards will be implemented
alongside changes to Oakland’s RD, RM, and RU
zones as described in Action 3.2.1.
| Reduce constraints to development
to significantly increase production of housing
to match housing need.
| 2023 |
3.2.1 | The City will review and amend the Planning
Code and implement objective design standards
to encourage missing middle-density housing
typologies, including flats, duplexes, multiplexes
(triplexes, and fourplexes), bungalow courts,
rowhouses/townhomes, and ADUs. The City
will work to reduce pre-development costs
and expedite the planning approval process for
missing middle housing types resulting from both
new construction and the conversion of existing
structures.
The City will develop zoning standards that
allow for two, three, and four units on parcels
in Detached Unit Residential (RD) Zones and
additional multi-unit housing types in Mixed
Housing Type Residential (RM) Zones. The City will
also reduce the minimum lot size in Detached Unit
Residential and Mixed Housing Type Residential
lots to 2,000 square feet to remove constraints
on lot splitting. The City will permit a variety of
building types (attached, detached, bungalow
courts) to maximize flexibility, neighborhood scale
and potential opportunities for homeownership
(split lots and condominiums) in parallel with Policy
3.4 and Policy 5.1. See Appendix J for a summary of
missing middle zoning amendments.
Under Action 3.4.1, the City will revise development
standards, including allowable building heights,
densities, open space and setbacks requirements.
Under Action 3.4.8, the City will develop objective
design standards at the neighborhood level to
ensure that multi-unit neighborhood scale housing
types designed in a manner that is compatible with
the scale of existing residential housing forms in
these zoning districts is permitted ministerially.
| Significantly increase production of
multi-unit housing types (including duplexes,
triplexes and fourplexes, along with other
multi-unit housing types) in current single-family-dominated neighborhoods to match
housing need.
| June – July 2023 |